UN Geneva Press Briefing - 29 October 2024
/
46:27
/
MP4
/
2.7 GB
Transcripts
Teleprompter
Download

Press Conferences | FAO , OCHA , OHCHR , UNICEF , WHO

UN Geneva Press Briefing - 29 October 2024

TOPICS

- OHCHR - Seif Magango: Sudan: Escalating violence in Al Jazirah – reports more than 100 killed in recent days
 
- WHO/FAO - Francesco Branca, Director, Department of Nutrition and Food Safety, WHO and Nancy Aburto, FAO Deputy Director of the Food and Nutrition Division (From Rome): Joint FAO/WHO statement

UN GENEVA PRESS BRIEFING

29 October 2024

Situation in Sudan

Amy Pope, Director-General of the International Organization for Migration (IOM), speaking from Port Sudan, stated that she was in Sudan for a four-day visit, where the security situation was deteriorating and could be described as catastrophic. This was an underreported conflict in which millions were suffering, and it was possible that it would ignite regional instability. A year and a half had passed since the start of the fighting, which was now also being fueled by external forces. Some 25 million people in Sudan were now requiring assistance. Throughout this year, Sudan had been the world’s worst displacement crisis; this week the IOM would release new figures which would show that as many as 11 million people were now internally displaced. More than half of those displaced were women, and a quarter were children under five. Unfortunately, many of them had been forced to flee repeatedly, and getting their basic needs met was very difficult. People did not have access to shelter, safe drinking water, or medicine; hunger was spreading, and famine conditions were taking hold in North Darfur.

Ms. Pope said that the safety of aid workers and UN staff was often threatened, and bureaucratic impediments were blocking delivery of humanitarian aid. All parties needed to ensure protection of civilians and ensure safe, swift, and unimpeded access to life-saving assistance. Help of the international community was needed now for this most neglected crisis. IOM’s part of the relief plan was only 20 percent funded, she informed. All wars were brutal, but the toll of this war was truly terrifying, stressed Ms. Pope. There were way too many reports of rape, sexual violence, and torture. The potential long-term impact of this crisis was staggering, with a generation that would live in the shadow of this trauma. A peaceful Sudan could take care of itself as it had immense resources. Guns in Sudan had to fall silent, and the humanitarian response had to be scaled up. End the hostilities, protect civilians, allow humanitarian access, and increase international support, plead Ms. Pope from Port Sudan.

On 28 October, the UN Secretary-General had addressed the Security Council on the situation in Sudan, informed Rolando Gómez, for the UN Information Service.

Responding to questions from the media, Ms. Pope explained that most of the IOM’s work in the world, including Sudan, was about supporting displaced people, wherever they were. Before the war, the IOM in Sudan had focused on supporting vulnerable communities and improving their access to livelihood; now, the IOM was helping millions of displaced people, including third-country nationals. IOM was working very closely with its UN partners to provide as much support as possible. Speaking of access, Ms. Pope said that in certain parts of the country, the IOM had been able to provide direct support to people in need. However, the IOM and partners were facing serious obstacles accessing many people who desperately needed help. The situation in the country was quickly evolving, and many people were being displaced numerous times. IOM’s Displacement Tracking Matrix showed that there were 11 million internally displaced people (200,000 more since the previous month) across the country, and 3.1 million people who had left the country. Of the 11 million IDPs - the largest number in the world - the IOM had managed to reach and support some three million people, because of limited access and limited funding (of the USD 168 million, only 20 percent had been received thus far). The needs of people to have access to food are overwhelming. IOM was concerned that the fighting was continuing and even accelerating, while the international community seemed not to be as focused on Sudan as it was on other crises in the world.

Seif Magango, for the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), said that UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk was extremely concerned by the escalating hostilities and violence in Sudan’s Al-Jazirah State, which were further exacerbating the risk of attacks against civilians, ethnically motivated violence, and atrocity crimes. Since the defection of Abu Aqla Keikel, a commander in the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), to the Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) on 20 October, attacks by the RSF on villages in Al-Jazirah state had increased, apparently in retaliation for his defection, and targeting members of his ethnic group. On 25 October, at least 124 people had been reportedly killed in an attack by RSF ground forces on Al-Seriha village, with unconfirmed videos showing dozens of bodies lined up for burial.

As a result of the violence, thousands of families had reportedly been displaced from Al-Jazirah state into the neighbouring states of Gedaref and Kassala, adding to the already dire displacement crisis in the country. Ms. Magango said that the OHCHR was also concerned by the increased calls for mobilisation of civilians in Al-Jazirah state, and reports of hate speech circulating on social media. The leaders of both sides had to promptly take all measures to de-escalate the situation. UN High Commissioner for Human Rights reiterated his call on all parties to strictly respect their obligations under international humanitarian law and international human rights law, in particular by ensuring the protection of civilians. All alleged violations had to be investigated and those responsible brought to justice, following fair trials.

Full OHCHR statement is available here.

Answering questions from the journalists, Jens Laerke, for the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), informed that out of the USD 2.7 billion needed for Sudan’s 2024 humanitarian response plan, 56 percent was currently funded. UN had received horrendous reports of civilians killed and displaced in Al-Jazirah state, who needed immediate attention, said Mr. Laerke. There were also reports of sexual and gender-based violence.

Israel’s Parliament vote on UNRWA

Answering questions from the media on the vote of Israel’s Parliament (Knesset), Amy Pope, Director-General of the International Organization for Migration (IOM), said that the needs of the Palestinian people could not be met without United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA). While others were already helping and stood ready to do more, UNRWA played the central role, said Ms. Pope. Many of the tasks performed by UNRWA were not conducted by other agencies, including the IOM, which had different roles to play. There was no way for the IOM to step in and perform UNRWA’s role, emphasized Ms. Pope.

Rolando Gómez, for the UN Information Service, informed that the Secretary-General had issued a statement on the Knesset’s adoption of two laws concerning UNRWA, which, if implemented, would likely prevent UNRWA from continuing its essential work in the Occupied Palestinian Territory. There was no alternative to UNRWA. The implementation of the laws could have devastating consequences for Palestine refugees in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, which was unacceptable. The Secretary-General called on Israel to act consistently with its obligations under the Charter of the United Nations and its other obligations under international law, including under international humanitarian law and those concerning privileges and immunities of the United Nations. National legislation could not alter those obligations. Full Secretary-General’s statement can be found here.

Jens Laerke, for the Office of the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), said that numerous UN agencies said that UNRWA was crucial and irreplaceable. He explained that the Knesset’s decision had led to an outpour of protest by numerous UN agencies and national leaders from around the world. UNRWA’s mandate came from a General Assembly’s resolution, reminded Mr. Laerke. For decades, UNRWA had been the backbone of what the UN had been providing for the Palestinian refugees, and there was no alternative to it. If implemented, the decision to banish UNRWA would add to the collective punishment of the people of Gaza.

James Elder, for the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), stressed that if UNRWA was unable to operate, we would likely see a collapse of the humanitarian system in Gaza, and UNICEF too would be unable to operate. Suspension of UNRWA would mean that a new way was found to kill children in Gaza. Conservative reports spoke of 14,000 boys and girls having been killed in Gaza over the past year. Mr. Elder spoke of all children who might have miraculously survived bombings of their homes and were left with serious injuries were now not being allowed to be medically evacuated. If you took away healthcare workers and other humanitarians providing lifesaving supplies, there would be an inevitable increase in children’s deaths.

Tarik Jašarević, for the World Health Organization (WHO), said that 3,000 out of 13,000 UNRWA staff were health workers, who had provided over six million medical consultations in 2023. They were also doing immunizations of children, screening for disease surveillance and malnutrition. These tasks could not be matched by any other agency, including the WHO. Only seven out of the 28 requested medical missions to the north of Gaza had taken place this month.

Jeremy Laurence, for the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), said that the Knesset’s decision was deeply troubling. The delivery of food, shelter, healthcare, and education would grind to a halt. Civilians had already paid the highest price of the conflict over the past year, and this decision would only make the situation far worse for them.

Healthy diets

Francesco Branca, Director, Department of Nutrition and Food Safety at the World Health Organization (WHO), speaking from Rome, said that food insecurity still affected over 750 million people in the world, while as many as three billion people could not afford healthy diets, leading to eight million deaths per year. It was also the second largest cause of disability globally. WHO and FAO had put together a guidance on healthy diets, which were needed to promote health and prevent both communicable and non-communicable diseases. Healthy diets were needed over the course of life, from the very beginning, and they could be achieved in all parts of the world, where sufficient food was available. Healthy diet should be adequate in nutrition, providing all essential nutrients in right amount; they should include protein, carbohydrates, and fats. Sodium consumption had to be limited to maximum five grams per day, while the consumption of refined sugars, trans fats, and red and processed meats should also be limited. Food should be consumed from different food groups, as well as different foods within various food groups.

Nancy Aburto, Deputy Director of the Food and Nutrition Division at the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) stated that good nutrition was dependent on many factors but eating healthy diets was essential. Achieving good nutrition, based on adequate, balanced, moderate, and diverse diets consisting of safe food and beverage, had the power to drive at least 11 of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals. For example, explained Ms. Aburto, achieving good nutrition based on diets that include adequate amounts of iron could support addressing anaemia in women and therefore allow more than 500 million women suffering anaemia today to have a better opportunity at experiencing improved quality of life so they can reach their potential and personal fulfillment, driving SDG5. Achieving good nutrition based on diets that include balanced energy across protein, fat, and carbohydrate enabled child development so they could reach their full health and productive potential adding billions to national incomes and pulling millions out of poverty, driving SDG1. Achieving good nutrition based on diets that were diverse could support reducing maternal and child malnutrition could save more than two Million lives of children under five every year, allowing children and families to live with good health and well-being, driving SDG3.

Ms. Aburto stressed that achieving good nutrition based on diets that were moderate in foods and nutrients of public health concern could reduce the burden of non-communicable diseases responsible for most of the premature mortality globally allowing millions more people to be free of disease and reach their full potential as productive members in society. Healthy, productive people drove action needed to reach targets across all the SDGs. Therefore, enabling healthy diets for all was the core not only to a food systems agenda but to Agenda 2030, concluded Ms. Aburto.

More information from the WHO and the FAO on healthy diets is available here.

Answering questions from the media, Dr. Branca, for the WHO, said that labelling might impair humanitarian food distribution, but the WHO was still looking into this subject. Ms. Aburto, for the FAO, said that access to healthy diets was a shared responsibility between governments, food producers and distributors, and individual consumers.

Other Issues

On questions related to the Sahel, Amy Pope, Director-General of the International Organization for Migration (IOM) said that the crisis in the region was compounded with a number of factors, including climate, extremism, and conflict. IOM was working closely with the communities in the Sahel and helping with a range of actions, but it was very underfunded.

Regarding the situation in the US, Ms. Pope said that the IOM hoped to continue working with the US Government, regardless of who was in charge. It was hoped that the us Government’s support to the IOM would continue. IOM hoped to help enable people move through safe, regular channels. Too often, governments focused just on the border, said Ms. Pope, while approach to migration ought to address root causes of migration and be truly multifaceted. It was a complex issue which needed a cross-sectorial, cross-country approach and focusing just on what was happening at the border was too narrow of a view.

Announcements

Rolando Gómez, for the United Nations Information Service (UNIS), reminded that today at 12 noon, Trade and Development Report 2024: Rethinking Development in the Age of Discontent would be launched in a hybrid press conference. The report, under embargo until 2:30 pm today, would be presented by Rebeca Grynspan, UN Trade and Development Secretary General, and Anastasia Nesvetailova, Head of Macroeconomic and Development Policies Branch, Division on Globalization and Development Strategies at UNCTAD.

He informed that the Human Rights Committee would conclude this afternoon the review of the report of Ecuador.

The Committee Against Torture was beginning this morning its review of the report of Kuwait.

On 1 November, reminded Mr. Gómez, the United Nations International Media Seminar on Peace in the Middle East would take place in room XXVI from 10:30 am. The seminar would discuss two themes: “Freedom of the Press and Safety of Journalists in a Time of War” and “Behind the Headlines of Gaza: Media Challenges and Perspectives.” More information is available here.

Mr. Gómez highlighted the Secretary-General's message for World Cities Day, observed on 31 October, emphasizing this year’s theme, Youth Climate Changemakers: Catalyzing Local Action for Urban Sustainability. The message is available here.

Finally, Mr. Gómez informed that the Secretary-General was in Cali, Colombia, where he would attend the 16th United Nations Conference on Biological Diversity. His remarks would be shared with the media later today. 

Teleprompter
Thank you again, colleagues. And, um, once again, Good morning.
Thank you for joining us at this press briefing here at the UN office at Geneva today,
the 29th of October.
Uh, we just heard from, uh, Amy Pope, Uh, the Director General of the IOM.
Now, we're going to hear from our colleague safe from the,
uh, human rights office, the UN Human rights office. And as I mentioned earlier,
uh,
just wanted to make sure you're all aware and saw the
statement that we shared with you yesterday from the Secretary General
on Sudan.
Uh, among other things,
he's calling on both sides of the conflict
to immediately agree to a cessation of hostilities,
uh, that civilians must be protected. And the third priority he outlined is
the flow, the urgent flow of humanitarian aid. And we just heard,
uh, a very dire report from Miss Pope on the situation in Sudan.
We're going to hear more on the human rights angles on the situation here, then, uh,
Sudan from safe.
So over to you Safe.
Uh,
UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volka
Turkey is extremely concerned
by the escalating hostilities and violence in Sudan.
The violence is taking place in Al Jazeera state
and is further exacerbating the risk of attacks against civilians,
ethnically motivated violence and atrocity crimes.
Since the defection
of Abu Ala
Keel,
a commander in the rapid support forces to the
armed forces on 20 October
attacks by the
on villages in al Jazeera state have increased,
apparently in retaliation for the defection,
UH, and targeting members of his ethnic group.
On Friday, 25 October, at least 124 people were reportedly killed in an attack by
ground forces on al
Sharia village,
with unconfirmed videos showing dozens of bodies lined up for
burial.
This incident follows at least two other attacks by the
ground forces on the nearby towns of Tam
and Rufa
earlier in the week.
Reports suggest hundreds of people were killed in Tambo
amid widespread lootings.
They indicate at least 25 cases of sexual violence in multiple villages
in shark al
Jazeera locality,
including three medical personnel
and an 11 year old girl
who
died as a result.
Women and girls were also reportedly abducted.
In addition,
there are concerning reports that the
detained and ill treated civilians from the targeted villages
and confiscated Internet devices and telephones in some 30 villages,
cutting off vital
channels of communication.
Further, there are reports of burning of crops
at a time when over 25 million Sudanese are facing acute food insecurity.
Because of the ongoing conflict,
destruction of crops in a region considered the country's
breadbasket can only exacerbate an already catastrophic situation.
As a result of the violence,
thousands of families have reportedly been displaced from Al Jazeera state
into neighbouring states of Garre
and
Kassala,
adding to the already dire displacement crisis in the country.
An estimated 8 million people have been internally displaced across Sudan
since the armed conflict broke out in April 2023.
We are also concerned by the increased calls
for mobilisation by civilians in Al Jazeera state
and reports of hate speech circulating on social media.
The leaders of both sides must promptly take
all measures to de escalate the situation.
The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights
Volk
reiterates his call on all parties to strictly
respect the obligations under international human rights law
and international
law
in particular in particular by ensuring the protection of civilians.
They must also
they must also
put an end to the violations committed by their forces.
All alleged violations must be investigated and those
responsible were brought to justice following fair trials
to break this horrendous cycle of violence.
Thank you.
Thank you very much. Safe.
And, uh, I note that you've shared the statement with, uh, colleagues.
You should have the statement that was just read out, uh, in your inbox.
And I should also mention that we have colleagues online
who are able to address and also in the room
here who are able to address the situation with the
ends. Uh, tower from WHO
James Uh, UNICEF and also Baar from UN HCR. Should you have questions for them?
Um
OK, we'll turn now for general questions on
safes briefing.
OK, I don't see any hands raised here.
Ok? And colleagues, if you want to add anything, just put your hands up.
I think this pope was actually very exhaustive,
very comprehensive on the very dire situation.
And again, I point you to the SG statement we shared with you yesterday.
I
do have OK, we have a question from Gabby of El
Proceso.
Gabriella.
Yes.
Thank you very much.
Uh uh, I would like to ask about the funding for for Sudan.
How is, um if if if it's uh
yeah, what is the situation on the funding for the crisis there? Thank you.
I think Jens is making his way to the podium.
I think he's best placed to answer this question.
We heard a little bit, of course, about, uh,
the funding situation from IOM from his pope.
But Jens will, um,
add from the archer perspective.
Just give us a second.
Thank you very much. Uh, good morning, everyone.
So we have, as you know, a humanitarian response plan for Sudan for 2024
it's asking 2.7 nearly $2.7
billion
and it's currently 56 per cent funded, which means that it has received
about $1.5
billion
so
slightly over half funded. But we also very late in
the year
Let me just add also from our side from the humanitarian side on this
development, we are seeing in Al Jazeera State
that the acting under Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs,
George Msuya,
has said that the UN has received horrific reports
as we have just heard of civilians killed,
detained and displaced in huge numbers.
And she
noted that many need urgent medical attention.
We have also heard from the humanitarian co ordinator
there
who
said
in
a
statement that was issued over the weekend.
The humanitarian co ordinator, there being Clementine
Salami
that she is shocked and deeply appalled
that human rights violations of the kind we have witnessed in Darfur last year,
including rape, targeted attacks, sexual violence and mass killings, are
seemingly being repeated now in Jazeera
state.
So a very, very concerning development and spread of that kind of warfare,
which is utterly unacceptable
indeed. Thank you very much. Jens. Uh, we have a question from Emma of Reuters.
I'm not sure if it's for Jens or maybe safe. Uh, Emma?
Uh, yes. Uh, can I ask a question to yens about
Anna as well? Is it the right woman?
Let's stay with Sudan.
Just for the moment, we will address UNRWA,
but I just wanted to exhaust the situation in Sudan.
Is this Do you have a question on Sudan or anyone else for that matter?
No. OK, uh, Gabriella, perhaps Gabby.
Is this a follow up,
Gabby?
Yes. Thank you. No, it's not a follow up II.
I just wanted to ask something to the Human Rights Office. But after that, we
finish with Sudan.
OK, let's do this. Then.
Let's just if there are no questions on Sudan, maybe since safe is here,
we will address U NRW and other colleague may ch in on U NRW.
So let's
maybe if you could pose your question to safe on another subject,
as there are no other questions on Sudan.
So, Gabby, please go ahead.
Yes, thank you. Uh, I would like to ask about Mexico
and the new judiciary reform.
Uh, that the official is the party,
um, gave to the senate and the parliamentarians and,
uh, this this reform, um, attacked the the independence of the judiciary system.
So democracy in Mexico is kind of, uh,
a very weak. So I don't know if you have any comments on that or
if you can say something. Thank you.
Hi, Gabriela.
Thanks for your question.
No, we don't have comments yet on that,
but we can get back to you in writing from the office. Thank you.
Ok, thanks. Uh, thanks in advance for that safe.
Um, do we have further questions for safe.
No, I don't see that's the case. OK, so what?
Maybe what we'll do is I appreciate, uh, that many of you have, uh, honour
on your minds. Uh, of course we do as well.
Uh, so maybe we'll we'll take your question, Emma.
And we do have colleagues from WHO and FA O who are online who will brief us.
Uh, Tarik is also, um, online to brief us on the situation of, um, of food safety
and nutrition.
But Emma, maybe if you want to pose your question to, uh, Jens and, of course,
uh, afterwards, maybe I I'll just recite, uh, uh,
parts of the SG statement that we shared with you last night.
But your question first. Emma, go ahead.
Sorry I couldn't unmute myself. Um,
yeah. Uh, I I'm wondering yen, but also WHO or whoever.
Um, do you think there is an immediate risk then of
shutting down its remaining operations in Gaza?
Um, there was some question about that,
whether it just applied to Israel or whether it would impact Gaza.
And just if you could respond on, um, Jamie's question to Amy Pope.
Uh, what is your position on whether you can fulfil some
of the functions of UN R,
um, presumably not the infrastructure roles,
but some of the kind of emergency support roles could
aha or WHO or others step in at least temporarily to, uh,
take on that role. Thank you.
Thank you, Emma.
Uh, actually, on on your first question, I think I will let um, Rolando, uh,
go to the SG statement.
Uh, which addresses that?
Thanks,
Jania colleagues. You did receive a statement that we shared with you last night.
It
was early this morning from the Secretary General
following the announcement at the Knesset of Israel.
I'm just going to recite some some of it,
um, for for the record here as it came in, uh, rather late in New York time.
Um, Secretary General is deeply concerned
by the adoption, uh,
yesterday by the Knesset of Israel of two laws concerning
the United Nations Relief and Work Agency for Palestine refugees
in the Near East, otherwise known as UNRWA, which, if implemented,
would likely prevent UNRWA from continuing its
essential work in the occupied Palestinian territory,
including east Jerusalem.
As mandated by the UN General Assembly,
UNRWA is the principal means by which essential assistance is applied to Palestine
refugees in the occupied Palestinian territory and
there is no alternative to UNRWA.
The implementation of the laws could have devastating consequences
for Palestine refugees in the occupied Palestinian territory,
which is unacceptable.
Secretary General Calls on Israel to Act consistently with obligations under the
Charter of the United Nations and its other obligations under international law,
including under international humanitarian law
and those concerning privileges and immunities of the United Nations
national legislation cannot alter those obligations.
The implementation of these laws would be
detrimental for the resolution of the Israeli
Palestine conflict and for peace and security in the region as a whole.
And as the secretary General has said before, UNRWA is indispensable.
Secretary
General is, uh,
bringing this matter to the attention of the UN
General Assembly and will keep the Assembly closely informed
as the situation develops.
Uh, this was a statement we did share with you last night.
And of course, since then there's been an outpouring from various principal
agencies, heads of agencies
on the decision yesterday. But back to you, Jens.
Thanks, Rolando. Indeed, an outpouring from
principles in the United Nations system.
I'm just looking at some of them calling UN.
There is no alternative.
Crucial.
Only UN
a has the mandate, a vital lifeline and so on and so forth
from my boss George. So
the acting on the Secretary General,
she said last night Full solidarity with UN W A and
its brave teams whose work is essential to millions of Palestinians.
The decision is dangerous
and it is outrageous.
There is no alternative to UN.
So I think that answers the question
Absolutely.
OK, colleagues and our apologies for our next briefers.
Because we do have a number of hands. This is an important issue.
So if you can indulge us and be patient, we start with Jamie A P.
Thanks. Thanks. Jentz. Uh, I'm gonna move my mouth away from the microphone.
I was told I speak to Lily and,
the, uh could you just tell us what concrete implications right now that this de
this decision by the Knesset has had is there
Is there anything that you've seen that has changed
physically on the ground since this K
Knesset decision,
um, has been made?
Um
and yeah. I mean, yeah, that's
Yeah. Uh,
thank you, Jamie. I think we can read in the
statement that he is.
We are trying
to not have an implementation of this
because it's not. The decision has been made.
We have seen an outpour of protests and not only from the UN but I dare say, from
very prominent government officials and heads of state, actually
around the world
calling this out as this is wrong
for a number of reasons,
I would say first and foremost for the millions of Palestinians who requires
help.
So I would refer to the
statement about the work that is ongoing now,
I think it also mentions that he will be in contact with the General Assembly.
As you all know, the mandate
of
is a General Assembly resolution.
Like the mandate of my organisation, for example,
uh, so that that is where the the the decisions
are made and discussed.
Thank you very much for that.
Uh, Jens and let me throw to James, uh, of UNICEF and Tarik also, um,
from WHO have their hands up.
So I suppose it's, uh, reacting to this situation. James.
Thanks so much. Hi, everyone.
Yeah, just from a UNICEF point of view.
Uh, in terms of the amount of aid that we distribute across the Gaza Strip.
Um, so much with the support of UN.
A.
So to be very clear,
um, if UN R
a is unable to operate,
uh, it would likely see the collapse of the humanitarian system
in Gaza. UNICEF,
um, would become effectively unable to distribute life saving supplies here.
I'm talking vaccines. I'm talking winter clothes. I'm talking
hygiene kits, health kits, water,
water and sanitation RUTF on malnutrition.
And we know again we're knocking on the door
of famine and all range of of nutrition supplies.
So a decision such as this suddenly means that
a new way has been found, um,
to kill Children.
Thank you, James.
Trick WHO.
Thanks. Uh,
lets
be honest. So really, just to give some figures to explain how important
a NR a is when it comes
to, uh, delivery of health services. Uh,
3000 out of 13,000
UN R.
A staff are health workers.
Uh, they basically provided more than 6 million
medical consultations last year in the health centres that are run by
a
and they have been providing this consultation
for more than half of Gaza population.
They are also
doing, uh, uh, immunisation of Children.
Uh, they are doing, uh, uh, uh uh.
Screening for disease surveillance screening for for malnutrition.
They have been active in a polio campaign.
One third, uh, of of team members for polio. Uh, are,
uh uh,
So, uh, really, Uh uh, If you think like that 3000 of their staff are health workers,
it's it's really, uh, unmatched.
It could be it couldn't be matched by by any agency, including WHO.
Thank you. Tare.
Jeremy. Human rights.
Yes. Thanks. Rolando.
The High Commissioner this morning actually just spoke on this.
He says this decision is deeply troubling For many reasons,
he sees this as having a potential dire impact on human
rights of those de depending on U NRW A's assistance.
if I may go on step further and just say our
office has repeatedly raised concerns about
Israel's compliance with international law,
but can also point to its obligations under a range of human rights treaties,
including the Cornerstone International Covenant on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights, which Israel is party to.
To this extent, uh, without UNRWA
the delivery of food, shelter, healthcare,
education amongst other things to most of Gaza's population would grind to a halt.
Civilians have already paid the heaviest price
of this conflict over the past year.
Cruelly,
this decision will only make matters worse for them.
Far worse.
Thank you very much, Jeremy and colleagues.
And these are just a few of the comments that were, uh,
the reactions, uh, from the the decision yesterday at the Knesset.
So we have other comments from UN H ER from U NDP. Um,
and many others, too. Too many to recite here, in fact. But, um
um, we do have a couple of questions,
so I'll just take those online unless there are those in the room.
I don't see that's the case. So we'll turn to Gabby LA
process.
So I think you had another question on this subject.
Gabby,
go ahead.
Go ahead. We
hear you.
Yes, it it's not on Gaza. But since J
is there,
um, let's Let's, uh,
sorry, Gabby. I'm just gonna cut you off.
Let's just finish, because I think other colleagues want to.
Let's discuss the honour situation first, and then we'll move on to other subjects.
We still have other briefers online. Just to remind you
so, Christian GPA,
my question is the yens on Gaza
Would it not be possible to put a different hat on that organisation, For example, Or
if all the people who work for UN
R now would then be employees of
this problem would be solved? Or is that a naive suggestion?
I really don't want to speculate in that. What?
And if And but And we can rehab this and that and the other
it's not relevant
is and has been for decades since 1948. The backbone of
what the UN is providing to the Palestinian refugees in Gaza and other
countries in the region. It is indispensable. And there is no
alternative to it at
this point.
Absolutely.
Jamie. Hey, Pete.
Thanks. This is for James. James.
Um, I'd I'd like to, um follow up on your comment about the decision of the Knesset to,
to impede the work of UN
R A or to ban UN R. Um
uh, the, um And you You mentioned that, uh, decisions like this, Um
uh, mean that it means that a new way has been found to kill Children.
Could you elaborate on that? What do you mean,
James?
Yeah, yeah. Sorry.
Same old unmute
issue.
what I mean is that
reports at a conservative level are of 14,000 girls and boys having been killed.
OK, that's an unprecedented,
um, number, um, becomes ever more so if you look at the duration of this war.
And if you look at the population of Children.
So 14,000 girls and boys being killed and we've seen, of course,
ferocious attacks in the North very recently,
showing clearly that this level of attacks
of what has now been accepted are indiscriminate attacks
lacking all sorts of proportionality have not stopped.
So that's always been the case. But we'll just outline it to put it there. Anyway,
The second part is, of course, is the warnings that came from as far away as November.
That if you devastate the health system, the water system, the sanitation system,
then there is such an enormous risk.
We heard from medical experts WHO across the board, doctors on the ground,
such a huge risk of a disease outbreak.
And now, of course, we've seen the devastation to the health system,
the water and sanitation system. Um,
we see uh, we've seen famine on the doorstep.
We see polio now for the first time in a quarter of a century.
Um, so we have disease and we have bomba
disease on the ground bombardments.
Then, of course,
if you recall Jamie Bri when I briefed last week another way Children are dying.
Children are being killed, if you will. Is, um, this
wilful neglect to get medical evacuations for any of
those Children who have somehow miraculously survived a shelling or
a bombing on their homes and find their S themselves
with wounds that none of us could possibly imagine?
Just imagine the last time you burnt yourself and then imagine, you know,
your four year old child having fourth degree burns
and that hospital not being able to have the the
burn cream or anaesthetics or or painkillers that are required,
and then
that child not being allowed to leave the country,
those kind of injuries we are seeing Children,
um, dying from being killed from despite,
um, our best efforts. So that's a third way
now this way,
as you've heard from so many principals and
there were senior people in the United Nations
and I think Tarik explained it so well in terms of healthcare workers,
you takeaway the healthcare workers.
You takeaway the nutrition
support you takeaway the people who will provide the
life saving supplies for a population that is physically,
physically, absolutely on death's door.
And psychologically, of course, in unchartered territory,
you takeaway these healthcare workers.
You takeaway the nutritionists.
Then we will see many more Children die.
Um, so that's that's my my reasoning for that statement. Thanks.
Thank you for that. James. Uh, we have a questioner from Satoko
of Yomiuri
Shimbun.
Hello?
Hi.
Yeah. Hi, Satoko. We can hear you.
OK, this is a question to Tariq.
Uh, could you tell us the the status of the polio campaign in North
Gaza?
If there is any update since Friday last week.
And then also the implication of the
Knesset decision on
Rua
if on the on the polio campaign Thank you.
Thanks for the question.
Uh, yes.
I was briefing you last Friday on the postponement of the second round of, uh,
polio vaccination in the north.
Uh,
and then day after that, there was a raid on Kamal at one hospital,
Uh, and a number of staff had been detained.
Uh, and let me just update you on that. Our teams managed to get back to Kamal
at one. Yesterday.
Uh, they have found, uh, basically one orthopaedic surgeon, one paediatrician,
chief nurse and handful of, uh,
young doctors and junior doctors and nurses, uh,
trying to attend some 101 150 patients.
So, really, this shows how difficult it is to provide any sort of aid in north of Gaza.
Out of 25 requests for missions
this month,
only seven of them managed to take place. Others were either denied or were impeded.
So in this setting, while we don't have agreement on Humanitarian po,
that would cover areas where Children
are. It is difficult to imagine to have this second round of
of, uh, of the polio vaccination.
Uh, but, uh, but again, we will be, uh, uh, doing our best as we do,
trying every day to get some sort of agreement on that.
But also agreement on our movements
to bring to to those health facilities that are still working, uh, what they need.
Thank you very much for the elaboration.
Um, the numbers say it all Thank you very much, Tarik.
Ok, I think we've finished questions on this subject now.
Gabby, you have a question for Jens who's still with us.
Uh, and then we'll have to turn immediately thereafter
to our colleagues in Rome. So, Gabby, back to you.
Yes.
Thank you, Orlando. No, I just wanted to to say if,
uh this decision on UNRWA
it will be for, like,
a collective punishment
for the people of Palestine.
Uh, because, you know, Children are gonna die, but also, people are gonna suffer.
So
if if this can be catalogued as that
and then I have another question for you.
Well,
if implemented and I stress if implemented,
uh,
I think it is
a fair description
of what
they have decided here. If implemented,
that they should add
to the acts of collective
punishment
that we have seen imposed on Gaza.
Thank you, Jan. Uh, you want to pose your other question now, Gabby?
Yes.
Yes. Thank you very much. Uh, Rolando and
elections are coming in in the USA.
And if Trump wins, if Donald Trump wins,
how affected will UN humanitarian operations be?
Because
we know that during his term, Trump reduced funding for the UN.
So now he also threatened to do so. So
are you worried about this or
not?
Thank you, Gabby. We survived. We survived the last one.
We are still here,
so that would be my comment on that.
Ok,
just on the collective punishment issue, I should mention that Philip
Lazzarini did tweet last night.
Uh, shortly after this, uh, this this legislation act, um, the Knesset.
And And he does refer to how these bills increase the
suffering of the Palestinians and nothing less than collective punishment.
Using those words, uh, precisely
so colleagues to take a look at all the, uh, the utterances, Uh, on this, uh,
decision,
I think, uh, we are now done with, uh, this subject now. Thank you very much.
Jans and colleagues, uh, for for chiming in on this important,
important subject. Um, and again, apologies. Uh, Mr Branca and Miss
Auro
Francesco Branca, who you know,
is a director of the Department of Nutrition and Food Safety.
And Miss Nancy Aber
is a FA O deputy director,
um, for, uh, for the food and nutrition division, Um, of FA O.
But I think Tarik,
you maybe wanted to add something before we throw to our colleagues in Rome.
Tarek.
Yeah, th th thank you very much. Uh uh, uh uh, Orlando.
And, um And, uh, we have just sent a joint statement WH,
FA,
O. And, uh
and we just heard, uh, about, uh, millions of people,
uh, living in a food insecurity being hungry in Sudan.
People in Gaza are hungry, too.
So some of you may wonder and be surprised that we are talking about a a
healthy diet.
But if you really think about it, the food security is about healthy diets.
And if you think that, uh,
nutrition is one of the main,
uh, risk factors for non
communicable diseases that are killing
two out of three persons and it's a huge burden
on a on a health system in all countries, not only, uh, in developed countries,
but also in a lower middle income countries, but also in humanitarian emergencies.
It is important
that we talk about a healthy diet. And that's why
uh, we proposed this topic today
with, uh, doctor Francesco Branca that you already know. And, uh, Nancy
B
from
FA
O. So I'll give the floor to,
uh, to To doctor brenco
first.
Thank you very much, Tareq And, uh, good morning to all.
Indeed, as Tarek was saying, you know,
the scourge of food insecurity still affects, uh,
733 million people in the world as the latest report on the state of food security,
Nutrition says.
But the same report also says
that, uh, uh, 3 billion people cannot afford healthy diets in in the world.
And we know that, uh, consumption of unhealthy diet, as Tariq was already saying,
is responsible for many deaths every year is
responsible for 8 million deaths every year,
largely due to non communicable diseases.
But it's also,
uh, the second worst cause of disability and disease. Uh, you know, among all causes
in the world,
So, uh, FA, O and WO, uh, wanted to clarify,
uh, what healthy diet means
and, uh, have, uh, put together all the guidance in this year. Uh uh,
on the different elements to define healthy diet, you know,
why do we need healthy diet?
The healthy diets are needed
to promote, uh,
health to prevent communicable and non-communicative
diseases to support healthy lifestyle.
Uh, and, um, really, uh, promote. Well, being and and development.
And this has to be defined across the life course.
We need healthy diets in the very beginning.
This statement indicates that healthy diets can be
achieved in any part of the world.
So we
have, uh, uh, the adequate, uh, foods available in all parts of the world.
As long as these
principles are respected, the statement basically says
that healthy diet should first and foremost be adequate in nutrition.
Provide all the necessary uh, uh, nutrients in the right amount, not in excess.
The the the, uh, essential nutrients. Second,
the diets should have a balanced intake of, uh, macronutrients,
which means protein, fat and carbohydrates.
We shouldn't,
uh, eat more than a third of our energy, our diet from fats.
And we should largely, uh, provide energy from carbohydrates. Uh,
complex carbohydrate.
The third element is about moderation. There are elements which we need to limit.
Uh, first sodium salt salt is actually one of the greatest killer.
Uh, at the moment, we shouldn't.
We shouldn't, uh, uh, exceed five grammes per day.
We should also limit the consumption of free sugars to less than 10% of the energy
we should limit the amount of saturated fat to less than 10% of the energy.
We should limit the consumption of highly processed food.
We should limit the consumption of bread and processed meat.
And finally, Dutch should be diverse. We should eat food from different
food groups and from many foods, um, within, uh, a food group.
So these are the main elements.
Uh, that can, of course, be translated.
And I'll give the floor to my colleague Nancy Bhutto from FA O.
Thank you, Francesco. Good morning, colleagues.
It's a pleasure to be here with you today, um,
also showing the partnership that FA O has with our valued collaborator of WHO
and with our longtime colleague and friend Francesco Branca.
Francesco has already outlined the content of this
FA OWHO joint statement on healthy diets,
and we feel it's an extremely important contribution to the
efforts to unlock the power of nutrition for sustainable development.
Good nutrition is dependent on on many factors.
I think we we have reflected on that actually throughout today's conversation,
interestingly enough,
but we know that healthy diets are are absolutely essential,
and they are where good nutrition starts.
They're where good health starts
and achieving good nutrition based on these core principles.
Adequate, balanced, moderate and diverse
and consisting of safe foods and beverages has the power to drive at least 11 of the 17
sustainable development goals.
For example,
achieving good nutrition based on diets that include
adequate amounts of vitamins and minerals such as iron
can support addressing anaemia in women and therefore allow
more than 500 million women who suffer anaemia today
to have a better opportunity at experiencing an improved quality of life
so that they can reach their full potential and personal fulfilment.
And this can drive SDG. Five.
Achieving good nutrition based on diets
that include balanced energy across protein,
fat and carbohydrates can enable child development
so that all Children everywhere at all times can
reach their full potential for health and productivity.
Which data has shows has shown can add billions
to national incomes and pull millions out of poverty.
Driving SDG one.
Achieving good nutrition based on diets that include
diversity can support reducing maternal and child malnutrition,
potentially saving more than 2 million lives of Children under five every year,
and allowing Children and families to live in
good health and well being driving SDG three.
Achieving good nutrition based on diets that include
moderation of foods and nutrients of public health Concern
can reduce the burden of non communal diseases responsible
for the vast majority of premature mortality globally,
allowing millions more people to be free of disease
to reach their full potential as productive members of society
and healthy,
productive people drive action needed to reach targets across all of the SDGS.
Therefore,
enabling healthy diets for all is a core
not only to food systems transformation agenda,
but also to the 2030 agenda for sustainable development.
And we hope that this joint statement,
with its simple four core principles of a healthy diet,
can support that critically important effort.
Thank you.
Thanks to you both, Um very, very important messages is indeed.
And I believe, uh, that key shared these statements with you.
Uh, OK, we have a couple of questions for you, John Zara
Costa. So Frans van cut in the Lancet. John.
Yes. Uh, good morning.
Uh, I was wondering, uh, if you're following, um,
initiatives at the moment, uh, to have flexibility on food labelling, uh,
designated for food aid.
Is that something FA O and WHO support or are against
Thank you.
Who wants to take that?
I think maybe I can. I can start, Uh, just
maybe. I think I think John, you refer
to discussion,
which is taking place at the moment that
the Codex committee on food labelling in in Canada
and, uh and
we have we have, uh, uh, uh a concern
that, uh, the the the the Labelling, Uh, there might actually,
um, uh uh impair,
uh, the the the distribution of of the right food.
But we are looking at the situation and the discussion at the at the Codex
period.
Thank you. Francesco. Uh, Gabby of El Proceso
of Mexico.
Yes. Thank you, Rolando.
Um, my question is, um, who is responsible of the access to a healthy diet?
Uh, the governments
and also the situation in Venezuela.
Uh, I heard that 5 million people are hungry there,
So I don't know if if you have something to say about nutrition
in In in Venezuela. Thank you.
You want to
start?
I can start with this one. Thank you, Gabby, for the question.
Who's responsible for access to healthy diets?
I think it's a shared responsibility.
Um we'd like to support a strengthening of the entire food system,
which begins with producers, um, and actually begins before producers.
It begins with our, um, ecosystems.
And so I think we all have a shared response
in supporting healthy ecosystems,
helping producers that can produce the foods needed for healthy diets.
And the actors across, uh, the food supply chains,
the retail markets all the way to consumers ourselves that need
to also have our own agency so that we can participate
in what is our access and ability to consume healthy diets.
Thank you.
Thank you. And I the second question on Venezuela, I think,
so maybe I I can, uh I can comment. Uh uh, there, uh, in indicating,
uh, uh, that, uh, indeed, the, uh, uh, situation of access to food, uh,
is related to the, uh, economic situation of the country.
And, you know, the high,
uh, the high food cost.
Um, we
don't have, uh, uh, recent information around, uh,
the, um integrated phase classification. You know, there is
a A system to monitor the, uh, access to food.
So we don't have, uh, recent, uh, analysis around, uh, Venezuela, but certainly,
um What?
Uh, the analysis of the state of food security and nutrition has indicated is that,
uh,
a combination of economic downturns.
Uh uh, climate change and conflicts,
other situations that are responsible for other reasons
that are responsible for for food insecurity.
So clearly the the situation of Venezuela is affected by
by the economic situation.
Thank you for that. Francesco.
Do we have further questions for our colleagues
in Rome?
No, I don't see. That's OK.
So once again, uh, sincere thanks to you both, uh, Mr Branca and Ms
Ato for joining us and thank you also for your patience.
OK, so we almost finished here. Just wanted to, um thank you both.
I just wanted to recite a couple of things as usual to make sure you're all on track.
OK, so starting with the Secretary General's travels, Of course.
Uh, the statement that I shared with you earlier to write out on UNRWA
and Sudan as well. I referred to those statements.
Uh, I should mention that the Secretary General is currently in Cali,
uh, Colombia,
where he is, uh, scheduled to deliver remarks at the opening of the uh,
plenary session of the cop um, in
his remarks, he's expected to highlight that nature is life,
and yet we are waging war against it.
Uh, these, um, comments will be
we figure in his statement which we will share with you later today, shortly after
the as delivered version shortly after they are delivered.
Um, I should mention that the Secretary General, whilst
in in Colombia will also meet and engage in discussions with indigenous people
and local communities. So
we will keep you up to speed on his, uh, travel to Colombia at
this important event.
Uh, other events taking place here
in Geneva. We have the Human Rights Committee, which is concluding this afternoon.
Its review of the report of Ecuador
and the Committee Against Torture, which began its 81st session yesterday.
This morning is reviewing the situation,
uh, in Kuwait
and in this room in this seat in about 40 minutes from now,
we will have Rebecca Greenspan,
who is the secretary General of UN Trade and Development.
Uh, together with Anastasia
Neva
Teva,
who is UT
A's head of macroeconomic and development policies Branch. Um,
they're going to be briefing you.
It's an embargoed press conference on the publication
of the Trade and Development Report 2024.
Rethinking development in the age of discontent.
That's the report which should have been shared with you.
It's embargoed until 2:30 p.m. So the press conference in this room
at noon?
Uh, there is a meeting, this seminar rather that we have announced here a
asander has announced that to you
from this seat.
Uh um and it's called the International Media Seminar on Peace in the Middle East.
It's an event which the Department of Global
Communications is organising with support from U.
I,
of course, taking place this Friday, the first of November
in room 26.
Uh, we have, uh, Melissa Fleming, under Secretary General for DGC Tatiana Vallo
via Who's our director general at UN
O and, um,
Ambassador Riyad Mansour,
who is a permanent observer, um, of the state of Palestine to the United Nations,
based in New York.
We have messages from the Secretary General,
um, and the chair of the Committee on Exercising in a
rights of Palestinian people.
These are the messages that will open this this important, uh, full day event
with sessions speaking to the situation of, uh,
press and safety of journalists in a time of war.
And another session, uh,
is titled behind the headlines of Gaza Media Challenges and Perspectives.
We encourage you all
to show up at this important event. Uh, this Friday, the first of November,
Uh, starting at, um 1030 in room 26.
And lastly, just to mention that this coming Thursday,
the 31st of October is World Cities Day.
There is a secretary-general message that we shared with you.
This year's observance is
themed to youth climate change makers.
Cata
catalysing, local action for urban sustainability.
So there is a message which we shared with you on this important observance.
That's all I have. Do you have any questions for me?
No. On that note, I wish you good afternoon and see you here on Friday.